Undue influence over a Florida deed usually requires a confidential relationship, active procurement of the deed by the person who benefits, and a substantial benefit to that person. Courts also weigh signs such as isolation and vulnerability when deciding whether to set a deed aside.
Main Elements Courts Examine
Three core elements are usually needed: a confidential or fiduciary relationship between the influencer and the grantor, the influencer's active procurement of the deed, and a substantial benefit to the influencer. When these are shown, Florida law presumes undue influence, and the burden shifts to the person who benefited to prove the deed was the grantor's free choice.
Signs of Active Procurement
Florida courts commonly look at whether the person who benefits:
Was present when the deed was signed.
Was present when the grantor first said they wanted to make the deed.
Recommended the attorney who prepared the deed.
Knew what the deed said before it was signed.
Gave the attorney instructions for preparing the deed.
Found the witnesses for the signing.
Kept the deed after it was signed.
Other Factors
Courts also consider isolation of the grantor from family or advisors, mental or physical vulnerability due to age, illness, or dependency, an unnatural result, and the lack of independent legal advice. When these factors are present, a court may set aside the deed. An experienced Florida real estate or probate attorney can review a specific situation.